Saturday, October 29, 2005

POST: Just when you thought conservatives would follow Bush

Some may agree that Mrs Miers had very little support in the Senate, in order to be a nominee for the Supreme Court. The only one true supporter, here, was not Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.) it was President Bush by himself. All alone.

The complications of the matter would require a deeper analysis, yet, there is no more simplicity than the evidence: Judge Miers knew she had nothing to do without the support of the Senate. You can have the President's, sure, but that won't get you to the moon in a Nation that believes in its legal system, and it's ready to take it to the last consequences.

Of course, I'm not proud that a judge is turned down. This is a political affair, mostly, but the decision, and that's my point, is purely personal.

You can say "it's not fair! She would have been a great judge", and I'd say "maybe". But this has happened before -as Fred Barbash reminds us well in the linked article- so we don't have to grow desperate on the matter. I'm sure President Bush will find a suitable candidate for the Supreme Court, as he has found a "replacement" for Allan Greenspan in the Federal Reserve, a man that many thought would not leave office before the President did.

I would never aggree to call this a "victory of the most conservative wing", but as this comes up, it shows that not everybody in the Republican Party obbeys blindly to George W. Bush, and that's good in a way, as inner criticism makes us keep at least some attention in the real world. This time that criticism takes over, but for Bush this means that there's a broader change to be made: agreement. Within his own party, but also with those Democrats that can be reached. Forget Kerry's radical views. When it comes to the Supreme Court, it's time to negotiate.

Miguel Vinuesa

No comments: